Paul Thurrott on Apple TV:
For these reasons, Apple TV is recommended only for those people who have drunk the Apple Kool-Aid and decided they really like the taste and can afford the upscale lifestyle. General fans of digital media or those who are interested in accessing PC-based media from their TVs should know that there are better solutions out there.
That’s fine and all, but he also says:
For the same price, you could get an Xbox 360 and use that device to stream media from any XP or Vista-based PC, access live and recorded TV, various online music, movie, and photo services via its Media Center Extender functionality and a Media Center PC, or download rented and purchased TV shows and movies, many in high definition (unlike iTunes, which only offers standard definition video).
The Xbox 360 “tard pack” is $299, the same price as Apple TV. This does not include a hard drive, or high-definition cables (the box includes “low-def” composite cables, not component) so his point that Apple does not include cables is moot.
The $399 unit (that’s $100 more than Apple TV) comes with a hard drive (a whopping 20GB, with ~8GB free when you take it out of the box thanks to the system software), half the size of Apple’s. It also lacks HDMI output, so all content suffers from an unnecessary digital to analog conversion.
There’s also no internal wireless connection on the 360 (that’s $99 more), bringing the overall price to $100 - $200 over the price of the Apple TV.
But in all fairness, the Xbox 360 does do more:
It also plays DVD movies, and, heck, it can play high-definition video games too. Yes, the thing sounds like a wind tunnel, especially when its playing games, but it’s far more versatile and powerful device than the Apple TV. And it costs exactly the same price.
However, Paul fails to mention that the Xbox 360 has worse DVD playback quality than most $99 stand-alone units. Besides, can you really enjoy a film with the box screeching like a F16 the entire time?
As for games, not everyone looking for a media center device is in the market for a hardcore gaming console. Rewind back to 1977, it would be like buying an 8-track player with a pinball machine grafted onto it. Convergence, bleh.
Not to worry, BOHICA, Microsoft will soon roll out a $480 Xbox with a 120GB HDD and HDMI. If you add the external HD-DVD drive ($200) that’s quite an expensive (not to mention unsightly) media center device.
When you add it all up, if a high-end game machine *slash* media center device is what you’re after, you’re better off getting a Playstation 3. You get a Blu-Ray player, internal HDD, internal Wi-Fi, HDMI, and high definition gaming for $599, almost $200 less than the Microsoft solution. All in one nice, quiet package.
So, basically, I’d recommend Apple TV on the low-end, the PS3 on the high end.